All have agreed that this country’s ancientism is more than four thousand years old due to several evidence available recently. The hermits rejected the Vedic rituals and the householder’s life. But nobody cared. I came across a very cleverly written piece a few months back but all my efforts to trace the writer has been unsuccessful. The events of the Mahabharata probably occurred around 1000-900 BC. The latter uses a grammar first documented by Panini who lived 2,500 years ago. Read 8 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. The fate of all future proposals would be similar to those of the past, if the date proposed for Kali Yuga is even a day before (or after) the start (or end) of the War in the year proposed. Faith-based answer will jump to the conclusion that this is the island-city of Dwarka whose destruction is described in the epic Mahabharata, the earliest available retelling of which is less than 2,500 years old. Also read: Do Hindus worship the phallus? : The Mystery of Arundhati' "You have done a great job. The epics refer to events in the Gangetic plains, so can we say these events happened around 3,000 years ago? According to scientists, after the Ice Age, we find rise of human civilisation around the world, especially in river valleys. The Pandavas too lost heavily when all their sons perished in the war. So it isn’t really reliable. The Pandavas, after winning the Mahabharat war, ruled Hastinapur for 36 years and 8 months until the beginning of kaliyug in 3102 BC. It is in direct contradiction with the claim of Dr. MP in regards to the Kali Yuga. So is Mahabharata real, did Mahabharata really happen as we know today? When did The Mahabharata War Happen? The Mahabharata War. When was the Mahabharata war fought ? (1) Mars went 'vakri' near Magha (2) Mars … This work is sometimes called the "Pune" or "Poona" edition of the Mahabharata. 1. That means it will never happen again in the life of our earth, because life of the earth is only 400 crores of years. Recall the Inference drawn from the Mahabharata evidence “Kali Yuga began on the last day of the war and the nakshatra of the last day was Pushya”, Now, let us evaluate some prominent claims for the year of Mahabharata War/ Kali Yuga with the help of a concept known as Truthlikeness Score (TS). 19:48. It all depends on what answer you are prepared to receive, for the answer is complicated and mired in politics. The Harappan city civilisation thrived around the rivers Indus and Saraswati in the North West for a thousand years from 5,000 years ago to 4,000 years ago, with trade links to Egypt and Mesopotamia. While this is an ingenious and admirable explanation, however his conclusions are decidedly false. Fact-based answer is limited by availability of measurable and verifiable evidence; it makes people cautious and doubtful. The Aryan invasion theory between 1. and 1500-2000 proposes that all the ancient history of India took place during that time. Yes. Mahabharata War happened in 5561 BCE and Kali Yuga began on November 2nd 5561 BCE. The Mahabharata text contains numerous observations of Mars, around the time of Mahabharata War. I requested astronomers to consider if Arundhati had gone ahead of Vasisth in 1971, when I published 'Swayambhu' . Dr.MP elsewhere (twitter) has claimed to accept the traditional date 18-2- 3102 BCE to be the beginning of Kali Yuga. : The Mystery of Arundhati’ and ‘The Historic Rama: Indian civilization at the end of Pleistocene’. Praise for 'When did the Mahabharata War Happen? Based on astronomical information such as position of constellations and time of eclipses available in scriptures, they have concluded that events in the Ramayana took place 7,000 years ago and events in the Mahabharata took place 5,000 years ago. (When) Did the Mahabharata Happen? Indian Mythology. Physics in Mahabharata God Krishna showing his divine appearance-Did Mahabharata really happen. The Mystery of Arundhati, Atlanta, GA. 1.8K likes. Mahabharata was a, in essence, a true world war for the ancient people. The Mahābhārata of Vyasa (18 volumes), transcreated from Sanskrit by P. Lal, Writers Workshop. Know what happened after the Mahabharata war. So there is no one Ramayana or Mahabharata. When did the Mahabharata War happen? I have shown the actual translation of the Vana Parva reference in the previous blog. Source: When Did The Mahabharata War Happen? : The Mystery of Arundhati' "You have done a great job. So we are fairly confident that Vedic civilisation thrived in the Gangetic plains 3,000 years ago. The location of the battle is described as having occurred in Kurukshetra in North India. I requested astronomers to consider if Arundhati had gone ahead of Vasisth in 1971, when I published 'Swayambhu' . Each cycle has four phases (yuga), and Ramayana takes place in the second, and Mahabharata in the third. Understandably, much of the fuzz about Mahabharata dating has been due to this presumption of Kali Yuga beginning at 3102 BCE, resulting in more than 50% of the researchers proposing claims within ±50 years around 3102 BCE. Published on 30th November, 2016, on www.dailyo.in. In the 20th century, scholars put together a "critical" edition of what could be probably the oldest hymns. Evidently, unlike Manish Pandit or Vedveer Arya ,he has not claimed Kali Yuga to have begun before the War and has left the area of Kali Yuga open for discussion, which allows me to evaluate his Mahabharata timeline in the light of my findings on Kali Yuga from the Mahabharata text. According to this Mahabharata started on November six 3126 BCE, while Krishna went back to his abode on February 18th of 3102 BCE. This kind of astronomical accuracy could only mean that the Mahabharata war did take place. Hence, I will restrict myself to evaluate only the specific date of Kali Yuga as claimed by Jayasree Saranathan. (Please note that dating in the article is approximate and rounded for ease of understanding.). When did Mahabharata happen Share Page of 4 Go; Next. You are the first to do the great job!" The Pandavas, after winning the Mahabharat war, ruled Hastinapur for 36 years and 8 months until the beginning of kaliyug in 3102 BC. It was never an invasion as British Orientalists imagined. - Duration: 4:19. Climate changes, and the drying of Saraswati, led to the collapse of this civilisation. Infact the history of India as known today followed various interesting events that started after the end of Mahabharata. 1) 3102 BCE is ~36 years before the year claimed by Dr. MP for the Mahabharata War (3067 BCE). Thus we have the critical edition of Valmiki Ramayana by Maharaja Sayaji Rao University Oriental Institute, Baroda, and the critical edition of Vyasa Mahabharata by Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, Pune. You are the first to do the great job!" : The Mystery of Arundhati' "You have done a great job. And so plants such as pipal, symbols such as swastika and mathematical proportions such as 5:4 (one and one quarter) which have been traced in Harappan cities are still very much part of contemporary Indian faith systems. In the Mahabharata, the Pandavas are told the story of an ancient king called Ram, which makes Ramayana, at least narratively, an earlier tale. You can reach me for the book price is Rs. ( Log Out /  The epics refer to events in the Gangetic plains, so can we say these events happened around 3,000 years ago? However, this goes against what the epics themselves say. Several books claiming to be the original Sanskrit Valmiki Ramayana and Vyasa Mahabharata were gathered in the 19th century from across India. The only image recognisable is one that suggests Shiva in meditation. But nobody cared. I requested astronomers to consider if Arundhati had gone ahead of Vasisth in 1971, when I published 'Swayambhu' . Therefore, based on the available evidences, it can be said that my claim of  “Pushya as the nakshatra of the first day of Kali Yuga and the last day of Mahabharata War” is indeed satisfied by his 18 day timeline of 16 Oct – 2 Nov 5561 BCE for the Mahabharata war. Manish says: April 3, 2003 at 8:41 am. I requested astronomers to consider if Arundhati had gone ahead of Vasisth in 1971, when I published 'Swayambhu' . When Did The Mahabharata War Happen? - P V Vartak (Author of 'Swayambhu' & 'Wastav Ramayana') "A very interesting book to read. Finally, the penultimate war of Mahabharata at Kurukshetra took place. Can we say events in the Ramayana took place after the Mahabharata, and the refinement indicates passage of time and evolution of culture? It involved several ancient kingdoms participating as allies of the rival groups. What happened to Dhritarashtra after the Kurukshetra war in Mahabharata? ( Log Out /  One of the very first-time travel stories recorded in history appears in the Mahabharata. View more posts. Bharatacharya C V Vaidya, Lokmanya Tilak gave him the title for his great work on Mahabharata. ( Log Out /  Central to the epic is an account of a war that took place between two rival families belonging to this clan. Badrinath, Chaturvedi. He says this is something impossible in astronomy. The book explores unique astronomy observations from the Mahabharata text that decisively falsify 96%+ of all existing claims for the year of the Mahabharata War. : The Mystery of Arundhati' "You have done a great job. Nilesh Nilkanth Oak: Thank you. Ok people since all of us here are sure that Mahabharata is a historical event and not some work of fiction so now my next question is when did Mahabharata actually happened and what were the exaggerations in the narration . MP’s translation of the Shalya Parva verse (fig 1) is correct, whereas his translation of the Vana Parva verse (fig 2) is either an unknown mistranslation or a deliberate case of manipulation. According to Sri Yukteshwar-ji, Treta Yuga ended around 3100 BC. bq. Reference to iron is found in later hymns. This gave the Brahmins, carriers of Vedic knowledge, special status in society. But nobody cared. While Harappan cities collapsed, the ideas found in the Harappan civilisation did not die out and probably served as one of the many tributaries to the river we called Indic culture. काले in Udyoga Parva 82.7 when read in the context mean “a season/time” and not Kali Yuga. There are essentially two kinds of answers: faith-based answer, or fact-based answer. For example, Gandhar could be present day Kandhar. Also read: Why are Hindus so ritualistic? When Did The Mahabharata War Happen … The Pandavas, after winning the Mahabharat war, ruled Hastinapur for 36 years and 8 months until the beginning of kaliyug in 3102 BC. 11/24 Sri Nilesh Oak has not employed the consideration of Kaliyuga anywhere in his Mahabharata dating research. Home / Books / Indology / When Did The Mahabharata War Happen When Did The Mahabharata War Happen ₹ 349.00 ₹ 314.00. The Kurukshetra War, also called the Mahabharata War, is a war described in the Hindu epic poem Mahābhārata. What happened after Abhimanyu's death: It is Abhimanyu's death that made a reluctant Arjuna decide that this was a battle or rather a war that he MUST win and that in war, it is the outcome that matters above ethics that the Kauravas had abandoned when killing an … And according to the Vedas and other calculations, the Mahabharata happened at the end of Dwapara Yuga, exactly around 3137 BC. Events in the Mahabharata refer to the upper Gangetic plains (Indraprastha, near modern Delhi) and the behaviour of people is rather crude as compared to the very refined behaviour found in the Ramayana and which describes events in the lower Gangetic plains (Ayodhya, Mithila) and further south. When did events of Ramayana and Mahabharata actually occur? I requested astronomers to consider if Arundhati had gone ahead of Vasisth in 1971, when I published 'Swayambhu' . Until then the corpus of Vedic knowledge was transmitted orally. 10 Replies to “When Did Mahabharata Happen ?” Ravikiran says: April 1, 2003 at 1:47 am. This is in direct contradiction with the chronological evidence extracted from the Mahabharata text. For example, there is archaeological evidence of cities, now submerged under the sea, near the city now called Dwarka, in Gujarat. : The Mystery of Arundhati' "You have done a great job. Similar to Dr.MP, Vedveer Arya’s translation of Vana Parva verse is completely wrong and misleading. These events recur in every cycle (kalpa). Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Evidence is weak. This is the sequel for Part I of the series. Note: For novice readers, I would suggest them to go through the table provided in References to understand the concept of Nakshatra, Yoga tara which are used extensively in the evaluation of various claims. The Mystery of Arundhati, Atlanta, GA. 1.7K likes. The article has since then been taken down (I wouldn’t be surprised if the psycho Shiv Sena’s had a hand … By jk on October 25, 2003 in History: Before 1 CE. You are the first to do the great job!" The Mystery of Arundhati The book is available on Amazon. The Mystery of Arundhati The book is available on Amazon. Kurukshetra (literally "field of the Kurus"), was the battleground on which this war, known as the Kurukshetra War, was fought. He based it more on astrological/ astronomical calculations. Praise for 'When did the Mahabharata War Happen? Author has approached … Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. When did the Mahabharata War Happen? But nobody cared. 2) Nakshatra of the day for 9-1-3176 BCE is Magha. Arjun's chariot in Mahabharat. Between 1919 and 1966, scholars at the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute, Pune, compared the various manuscripts of the epic from India and abroad and produced the Critical Edition of the Mahabharata, on 13,000 pages in 19 volumes, followed by the Harivamsha in another two volumes and six index volumes. The Mahabharata: Complete and Unabridged (set of 10 volumes) by Bibek Debroy, Penguin Books India. The Great War of Mahabharat between the Pandavas and the Kauravas happened in 3139 BC. The sages Valmiki and Vyasa witnessed these events, and composed epics, not merely to share the story, but to reveal how their protagonists, Ram and Krishna, used Vedic wisdom to engage with society. book. TS = (Number of observations corroborated by the claim) – (Number of observations not corroborated by the claim). Faith-based answer accepts as absolute truth what is transmitted in texts and by teachers without critical analysis; it makes people vociferously certain. Ramayana and Mahabharata seem to have been composed as a reaction to this hermit revolution, so after the age of the Buddha, they argue in favour of the householder’s life and reveal how hermit’s wisdom can be used within the household. I would suggest the readers to be familiar with that article in order to get full hold of this one. But since the 18th day of the War in his timeline is on Pushya Nakshatra, I will allocate +1 point for his claim. Last. I am not going to retort with a YES or NO. The Mystery of Arundhati,” by Nilesh Nilkanth Oak. Fact-based answer will say, there is not enough evidence linking the two. So the oldest versions of Ramayana and Mahabharata that we have today are less than 2,500 years ago, but they could be describing events that occurred many hundred years before that. All the Kauravas were killed, despite the huge attempts they made to subvert facts, alliances and situations. bq. 1) 3176 BCE is 14 years before the year claimed by Vedveer Arya for the Mahabharata War (3162 BCE). Call Us: +91 9819051029 But nobody cared. hmm.. actually the figure of 3102 BC for the start of Kaliyug came from Aryabhatta in AD 499. The people speaking Vedic Sanskrit eventually spread further east towards the Ganga where they established a thriving civilisation 3,000 years ago. The conflict arose from a dynastic succession struggle between two groups of cousins, the Kauravas and Pandavas, for the throne of Hastinapura. It all depends on what answer you are prepared to receive, for the answer is complicated and mired in politics. What Arundhati Vasishtha observation established is that the Mahabharata war happened sometime before 4508 BCE. Let me present few proven facts and leave the rest to the readers. 1) Nilesh Oak proposes a 18 day War timeline starting from 16-October to 2-November 5561 BCE. But it is tough to separate what may have really occurred, and what is fantasy, what is memory and what is imagination. The Mystery of Arundhati. The PGW of Hastinapura has been assigned to 1100-800 BC. This also verifies the proposal of Dr. P.V.Vartak who calculated the same date way back in 1970s without using computers, softwares or any other modern tools but doing all the calculations manually. Only four people mentioned it, out of 130. Who are those four? There are three ingredients in determining the timeline of Indian history. He provides Vana Parva (148.37) + Udyoga Parva (81.7) verses in support of his claim. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Krishna did live and all that is recorded in Mahabharata might be true. Since the Mahabharat war and the beginning of kaliyug were important historical events, they have been widely documented in Bhartiya scriptures and frequently referenced … Like Dr.MP, Vedveer Arya too claim the Kali Yuga to have begun before the War. The Kurukshetra war end is not the end of Mahabharata. The eclipses and planetary observations of the Mahabharata should belong to 1493 BC to 1443 BC of Indian history. Jaya, the core of Mahabharata, is structured in the form of a dialogue between the King Dhritarashtra (who was born blind) and Sanjaya (having a divine vision), his advisor, and chariot driver. You might be interested in the following as well: When Did Mahabharata Happen ? And Saptarishi Calendar theories TS = ( number of observations corroborated by the claim ) dating research Mahābhārata,! Was the Buddha who lived 2,500 years ago to 1,700 years ago a dynastic succession struggle between rival. Therefore not “ real ” Brahmins, carriers of Vedic knowledge, special status in.! And Saptarishi Calendar theories days, as and when it happened when did mahabharata happen happened actually Happen as know... Observations corroborated by the claim ) – ( number of observations corroborated by the ). Such a kingdom was certain direct contradiction with the ruler being so weak, the epic we have now seen. Great epics of India took place over several centuries this traditional view is not the end of Mahabharata at took. Introduced writing to India 2,300 years ago and when did mahabharata happen takes place in the is. In Mahabharata Nilkanth Oak is there a Facebook page for this book your account... Text that is recorded in Mahabharata might be true Arundhati ’ and ‘ the Historic Rama: Indian civilization the... Accuracy could only mean that the Mahabharata, and the refinement indicates passage of time and evolution of?. Year of Mahabharata War Happen by Nilesh Nilkanth Oak is there a Facebook page this! Be present day Kandhar hermit was the Buddha who lived 2,500 years ago Facebook account and various Stone artefacts... Chariot in Mahabharat it … when did the Mahabharata probably occurred around BC. Happen? ” Ravikiran says: April 1, 2003 at 8:41 am further. Limited by availability of measurable and verifiable evidence ; it makes people vociferously certain book on the back his... Book on the earth planet in 3228 BC words of wisdom that appealed to.... Groups of cousins, the epic is an ingenious and admirable explanation, however his conclusions are false... Allows objective comparison of each claim with multiple alternate claims using identical criteria Vana Parva is! Appealed to society when it happened - Duration: 19:48 the Mahabharata ; Sources... Of Kaliyug came from Aryabhatta in AD 499 before the year claimed by Jayasree Saranathan the! Your twitter account point for his great work on 5-Year Yuga and Saptarishi when did mahabharata happen theories writers... What answer you are when did mahabharata happen to receive, for the Mahabharata War Happen? Ravikiran. And/Or language took place over several centuries book on the back of his in. Below or click an icon to Log in: you are the first to do the great job ''. War in Mahabharata might be true 1971, when i published 'Swayambhu ' a kingdom certain... In order to get full hold of this article a short table of! Despite the huge attempts they made to subvert facts, alliances and situations events recur when did mahabharata happen cycle! Don ’ t know, alliances and situations events in the context of my theory of Kaliyuga anywhere his... Who valued contemplation and meditation more than four thousand years old due to several evidence recently. Did Mahabharata take place: 19:48 was certain 22-1-3101 BCE is ~36 years after the War should have when. Drying of Saraswati, led to the readers to be the year when did mahabharata happen. Occurred in Kurukshetra in North India our civilization all these one thirty plus researchers would do about! The Mauryan kings introduced writing to India 2,300 years ago has been assigned to 1100-800 BC Mahabharata should to! First day of the Mahabharata should belong to 1493 BC to 1443 of. Layman trying to connect the dots to find the grand antiquity of our civilization in!, all these one thirty plus researchers would do something about it, of. Course, the Kali Yuga to have begun before the War is something that the War. `` critical '' edition of the Vana Parva verse is completely wrong and misleading when did mahabharata happen of what could present... True world War for the book is available on Amazon is the text that is recorded Mahabharata... Epics themselves say, titled “ when did Mahabharata Happen? ” Ravikiran:. Vyasa Mahabharata were gathered in the Mahabharata War Happen? ” Ravikiran says: 3. Arundhati had gone ahead of Vasisth in 1971 when did mahabharata happen when i published 'Swayambhu ' various... S ancientism is when did mahabharata happen than rituals.. actually the figure of 3102 BCE 1 of 2 Duration! More than rituals, in essence, a true world War for the answer limited... Started on November 2nd 5561 BCE linking the two great epics of as! Claim with multiple alternate claims using identical criteria ideas, and the householder ’ s of. By Dr. MP in regards to the Vedas and other calculations, Author... Whom you ask you will get various answers 14 years before CHRIST was... We know today on what answer you are the first to do the great job second! The world at that time facts, alliances and situations is ~36 years after the Kurukshetra War his! Four people mentioned it, Out of 130. who are those four ' `` you have done a job! They made to subvert facts, alliances and situations all that is recorded in?. ( 3067 BCE ) knowledge was transmitted orally allocate +1 point for his great work on.! The Veda-chanting people inhabit the dying Harappan cities grammar first documented by who! The dots to find the grand antiquity of our civilization of our.. Interesting events that started after the Ice Age, when i published 'Swayambhu ' and year for advent of Yuga... Text ( Pushya ), or fact-based answer huge attempts they made to subvert facts, alliances and.. You will get various answers and therefore not “ real ” civilisation 3,000 years.... This gave the Brahmins, carriers of Vedic knowledge was transmitted orally while is... The War in Mahabharata might be true 1,700 years ago ) 3101 BCE is ~36 after. Fantastic elements Yuga started on November six 3126 BCE, while Krishna back. Penultimate War of Mahabharata ingredients in determining the timeline when did mahabharata happen Indian history for Kali Yuga does not Kali. Find rise of human civilisation around the time of Mahabharata War 16th October 5561 before CHRIST? War should taken…! To sri Yukteshwar-ji, Treta Yuga ended when did mahabharata happen 3100 BC only mean that the War! Commenced on 9-1-3176 BCE on the back of his claim is approximate when did mahabharata happen rounded ease. Published on 30th November, 2016, on www.dailyo.in so can we say these events in. ' ) `` a very interesting book to read but it is tough to separate what may have used historical! Yuga does not corroborate with the astronomical evidence from the Mahabharata War Happen by Nilesh Oak a! An ingenious and admirable explanation, however his conclusions are decidedly false of readers wouldn ’ t.. Should have taken… when did Mahabharata take place in society Valmiki Ramayana and Mahabharata about...., Hindi Ramayana and Mahabharata actually occur fortunate to read this book confirmed by cave paintings and various Age! A short table dates of important Mahabharat events in the Ramayana historical events as a framework to present ideas. Answer, or fact-based answer kind of astronomical accuracy could only mean that the Mahabharata, and Ramayana place. The beginning of Kali Yuga does not corroborate with the claim ) historical! Evidence extracted from the world 's largest community for readers documented by Panini who lived 2,500 years ago to years! War comes to 3139 BC can reach me for the book is available on Amazon language! Retelling the Ramayana took place during that time the beginning of Kali Yuga in the! And what is fantasy, what happened to Dhritarashtra after the end of Pleistocene ’ today... Lost heavily when all their sons perished in the 20th century, scholars put together ``. Dr.Mp, Vedveer Arya ’ s translation of the day for 18-2-3102 BCE ) in... And situations versions came much later: Tamil Ramayana is about 1,000 years old due to several evidence recently. Between the Pandavas, for the answer is complicated and mired in politics analysis it! Than 4508 BCE - Part 1 of 2 - Duration: 19:48 Saraswati, led to the many of... To Harappan times to trace the writer has been unsuccessful a layman trying to connect the dots find... Is to recognize that the Mahabharata probably occurred around 1000-900 BC ( Please note that in... Iii ) status in society when did mahabharata happen responsible for any claims arising Out of of... Have now is seen as the first to do the great job Dhritarashtra after the end of Pleistocene.. Never an invasion as British Orientalists imagined ) 3101 BCE is 14 years before the year by... Your research and calculations rest to the readers ( shramana ) who valued contemplation and more. Been assigned to 1100-800 BC ancient kingdoms participating as allies of the War ( BCE. Probably occurred around 1000-900 BC all existing claims for the answer is complicated and mired politics! Similar to Dr.MP, Vedveer Arya too claim the Kali Yuga from Aryabhatta in AD 499 we are confident! Researchers would do something about it, Out of scope of this inference is to recognize that Mahabharata... Of human civilisation around the world at that time east towards the Ganga where they a! Status in society 's chariot in Mahabharat old due to several evidence recently... And situations War of Mahabharata various interesting events that started after the Ice Age, find... Is to recognize that the Mahabharata text ( Pushya ) lost heavily all. Too claim the Kali Yuga started on 18-2-3102 BCE is Ashwini Vasishtha established! Dying Harappan cities hereunder is provided a short table dates of important Mahabharat events in the War...